I haven't tried the eye liner. I have the gel eye liner and love it. The blush gives your skin a golden glow. And I'm very happy about the lipstick, both kinds.
I do have a hard time applying the eye liner. But it's not this make up. It's me with all eyeliners. I have been very satisfied with this make up. I would say it's much better than Lancome,borgese,clinique,Estee lauder etc.
Long wearing eyeliner, glides smoothly on lash line creating a well pigmented eyeliner can smudge to create a smoky look or keep it clean for a dramatic clean look. I just love it.
Favorite eye pencil because it lasts throughout my work day. Best of all it solves that problem I used to have where my old liners used to smear to my top eyelid... Thrilled I no longer have that problem. Love this stuff